Home » May 2019 » Archives for May 16, 2019

Day: May 16, 2019

Federal Court Says that Outside Advice is Not a “Get-Out-of-Jail-Free Card”

The United States Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit upheld the SEC’s decision that an investment adviser failed to fully disclose mutual fund revenue sharing even if it sought and relied on the advice of outside compliance consultants. The Court found that the adviser acted negligently by failing to fully disclose the conflict of interest inherent by receiving shareholder servicing payments for investing in certain funds offered by its broker/custodian. Although the record was unclear about whether the adviser sought or relied on an outside compliance consultant’s advice, the Court decided that it didn’t matter because “any reliance on such advice was objectively unreasonable because [the adviser] knew of their fiduciary duty to fully and fairly disclose the potential conflict of interest.” The Court did, however, throw out the SEC’s claim that the adviser intentionally filed a misleading Form ADV, because the SEC failed to show that the adviser acted with the requisite intent to deceive.

As we have previously reported, this case argues in favor of seeking outside advice because it will help defend against the claim that you acted with intent, which would draw more punitive penalties. However, the Court here makes clear that relying on outside advice, even though you (should) know otherwise, will not exonerate you from claims that you acted negligently.