The Massachusetts Securities Division has proposed a fiduciary rule for all brokers and advisers for the provision of recommendations, advice and selection of account type. The proposed rule would require that all recommendations and advice be made in the best interest of customers and clients without regard to the broker/adviser’s interests. The MSD asserts that the suitability standard has not sufficiently protected customers against sales contests, churning, risky products and bad brokers. The MSD also criticizes the SEC’s recently adopted Regulation Best Interest because it (i) does not fully protect investors; (ii) relies too much on disclosure; and (iii) does not resolve customer confusion about the applicable standard of care. The MSD is accepting comments until July 26.
The expansive MSD proposal includes any type of financial adviser, any type of customer, and any type of advice. If adopted, the MSD’s rule would set up a court case about whether Regulation Best Interest preempts state fiduciary rules.