Home » Compliance Blog » Initial Coin Offering

Category: Initial Coin Offering

Federal Court Rules that the SEC Must Prove that Digital Tokens are Securities

A federal judge has ruled that an initial coin offering may not constitute an offering of securities.  In rejecting the SEC’s request for a preliminary injunction against an ICO, Judge Gonzalo Curiel of the Southern District of California, opined that the SEC failed to present sufficient facts to satisfy the Howey test requiring an investment of money in a common enterprise with an expectation of profit produced by the efforts of others.  Faced with conflicting interpretations of how the ICO operated, the Court denied the preliminary injunction because of genuine disputes about material facts.

The significance of this decision is that a court is requiring the SEC to factually prove the three prongs of the Howey test rather than simply accept the SEC’s position that digital tokens are securities.  If the SEC fails to prove its case and digital tokens are not securities, the SEC will not have the legal authority to regulate ICOs. 

SEC Fines Two Initial Coin Offerings

The SEC ordered two initial coin offerings to offer investors rescission and pay a $250,000 fine for failing to register the offerings under the securities laws. These cases represent the first time that the SEC has imposed civil penalties solely for ICO securities offering registration violations.  One of the respondents raised $15 million by selling digital tokens intended to create a new digital coin ecosystem related to advertising and mobile phones.  The other respondent raised $12 Million to create a blockchain technology for the emerging cannabis industry.    The SEC maintains that the digital tokens are “securities” under the Howey test and, therefore, the offerings violated the registration requirements of the 1933 and 1934 Acts.  Both respondents undertook to register the offerings.

Given the SEC’s concerns about disclosure and compliance for ICOs, it will be interesting to see the extent of disclosure required in the promised registration statements.